Andrew PaullCollege Essay Coaching

College essay coaching · South Jersey, Princeton & Zoom

Your story, not your résumé.

A veteran English teacher and college writing instructor who helps students find the story only they can tell, and write it themselves.

  • 20-year high school English teacher
  • College composition instructor
  • Edutopia author
  • NCTE 2026 presenter
Andrew PaullWorks with juniors and seniors aiming at selective and Early Decision schools.
Personal statement · Example draftPrompt 2

As captain of the robotics team, I learned leadership, teamwork, and perseverance.

The trophy is on your résumé. What happened the night the arm snapped?

At 11:40 the night before regionals, our arm sheared clean off at the elbow, and every one of my teammates turned to look at me.

Word count0 / 650

Every word is your student's.

I coach. I never ghostwrite, and AI never writes or rewrites a word. That's what the Common App requires, and it's what makes an essay sound like the person who wrote it. Admissions readers can tell.

The method

Three stages, borrowed from the oldest story there is.

Most stuck essays are résumés in paragraph form. My brainstorming method adapts the Hero's Journey, the structure I've taught for years and presented at NCTE, to help students find a real story with a beginning, a turn, and a change.

1 · Separation

The moment you left the familiar

"Where were you before this started?"

We map the ordinary world a student came from and the moment something pulled them out of it. Small, specific moments beat big achievements.

2 · Initiation

The test, the struggle, the turn

"What did it cost you?"

This is the heart of the essay: what was hard, what the student didn't know yet, and the choice they made. We find the scene worth writing.

3 · Return

What you carry forward

"Who are you now, and what will you bring to campus?"

Reflection is what admissions readers remember. We shape the ending so it shows growth instead of announcing it.

Then the real work: outlining, drafting, and revising in rounds, with the student writing every sentence and me asking the questions that make the next draft better.

How to start

Three steps to start.

  1. Free fit call

    15 minutes · free

    A quick call with you and your student about schools, deadlines, and where the writing stands. If I'm not the right fit, I'll say so.

  2. Essay Discovery Session

    90 minutes · $175

    Brainstorming and topic mapping with your student. You leave with a written topic plan, whether or not you continue.

  3. Choose a package

    Personal statement or full application

    We draft and revise on a schedule built around your deadlines, in shared docs you can always see.

Packages & prices

Clear prices, and a small number of students each season.

I take a limited number of students so each one gets real attention. Hours include draft reading and written feedback between sessions.

December Supplement Sprint

For seniors with Regular Decision supplements due January 1–5, and for deferral letters. Focused hourly help, with a few spots open through January 5.

Ask about a spot

Essay Discovery Session

$175

Start here

90 minutes of brainstorming and topic mapping.

  • One-on-one with your student
  • Hero's Journey topic mapping
  • A written topic plan to keep

Summer Essay Bootcamp

$795

For rising seniors · 4–6 students

Students leave August with a finished personal statement draft.

  • Four 2-hour small-group sessions
  • One private hour for each student
  • Early sign-up opens in February
Where most students start

Personal Statement

$1,250

About 6 hours

The 650-word Common App essay, start to finish.

  • Brainstorm and outline
  • Three rounds of draft feedback
  • A final read before submission

Full Application Essays

$2,600

About 12 hours

The personal statement plus supplements for up to 6 schools.

  • Everything in Personal Statement
  • "Why us," community, and short-answer supplements
  • A plan for reusing material across schools
Hourly add-on · extra supplements, Regular Decision essays, and deferral letters
$175/hr

Packages are paid in full before the first session. Sessions need 24 hours' notice to reschedule.

When to start

The best time to start is junior spring.

Students who finish their personal statement over the summer go into senior fall with room to breathe. Here's how the year works.

We're here Feb – MayJunior spring

Discover a topic and start brainstorming.

Discovery Sessions, free parent talks, and Bootcamp sign-ups.

We're here Jun – AugSummer before senior year

Finish the personal statement before school starts.

The Bootcamp and the Personal Statement package. This is when I have the most openings.

We're here Sep – OctSenior fall

Early Decision and Early Action supplements, often due Nov 1.

Continuing students only. I don't start new full packages in the fall.

We're here Nov – DecSenior winter

Regular Decision supplements due Jan 1–5, and deferral letters.

December Supplement Sprint and hourly help.

250–650 words for the Common App personal statement 7 prompts, unchanged for 2026–27 Aug 1 the application opens

About your coach

Twenty years of reading teenagers' writing.

I've taught high school English in New Jersey since 2006, mostly to sophomores and seniors, and I teach first-year college composition as an adjunct. That means I know what strong high school writing looks like, and I know what college professors expect from it.

I'm also a parent going through admissions right now, so I know what the essay process does to a household in October.

I coach essays only. I don't build college lists, prep for tests, or advise on financial aid. When a family needs that, I refer them to people who do it well. Focusing on one thing is how I stay good at it.

Andrew Paull, smiling, in glasses and a navy shirt on a sunny city street
Andrew Paull, essay coach
  • 20 yrsHigh school English teacher
  • CollegeComposition adjunct, Comp 101 and 102
  • AuthorPublished in Edutopia on teaching narrative writing
  • NCTE2026 conference presenter on the Hero's Journey in student writing
  • NEHSNational English Honor Society chapter adviser
  • MentorMentor to new English teachers

Who this is for

Strong students who freeze on personal writing.

A good fit

  • Rising seniors, or juniors in the spring
  • Strong transcripts, aiming at selective or Early Decision schools
  • Students who write well in school but stall on "write about yourself"
  • Families in Collingswood, Haddonfield, Moorestown, Cherry Hill, the Princeton area, and the Philadelphia suburbs, or anywhere by Zoom

Not a fit

  • Families who want the essay written for them
  • The night-before-the-deadline rescue
  • Students currently in my own classes

For parents

You'll get scheduling, progress updates, and a clear sense of where things stand, without having to be the one asking "how's the essay going?"

For students

The sessions are yours. Your ideas, your voice, your words. My job is to ask better questions until the essay sounds like you.

Policies

The ground rules, written down.

The words are the student's

It's in every family agreement. I give questions, feedback, and line-level comments, never replacement sentences. This follows the Common App's policy on presenting someone else's language or ideas as your own.

AI policy

AI never generates or rewrites essay content. Basic spelling and grammar checks are fine. The Common App treats AI-written content as fraud, and some colleges limit AI use even further. Drafts live in shared docs with version history, so every change is visible.

Safety and privacy

A parent signs the agreement, parents are copied on all scheduling, and sessions happen on Zoom or in a public place. Student work stays private, and I never put it into AI tools.

Payment

Discovery Sessions are paid at booking. Packages are paid in full before the first session.

Rescheduling

Give 24 hours' notice and we'll find another time. Sessions missed with less notice count as used.

Separate from school

This practice is independent of any school or district. I don't coach students currently in my classes, and coaching is kept separate from any recommendation letter.

Questions parents ask

FAQ

Will you write the essay for my student?

No, and I won't rewrite it either. I give detailed feedback on every draft: what's working, what's unclear, and questions that push the next revision. Your student makes every change, so every sentence is theirs. That also protects them, since submitting someone else's writing is against Common App rules.

When should we start?

Junior spring is ideal for topic discovery, and summer is the best time to finish the personal statement. Seniors working on Regular Decision supplements can still get hourly help in November and December.

Do you help with college lists, testing, or financial aid?

No, I focus only on essays. If you need a full admissions counselor, I'm happy to recommend independent counselors I trust, and I'm glad to work alongside them.

Where do sessions happen?

On Zoom for most students, or in person in a public place for families in South Jersey, the Princeton area, and the Philadelphia suburbs.

How many sessions does a package include?

Packages are measured in hours, not sessions: about 6 for the Personal Statement and about 12 for Full Application Essays. That time covers our meetings plus my reading and written feedback between drafts.

What if we need more help than the package covers?

Extra supplements, Regular Decision essays, and deferral letters are available at $175 an hour. I'll always tell you before we go past a package's hours.

Can my student use AI tools at all?

AI never writes or rewrites content, but basic spelling and grammar checks are fine. College policies vary, and some, like Notre Dame, allow AI only for spelling, grammar, or brainstorming, so we follow one strict rule that works for every school.

My student is in your class. Can we work together?

Not while they're enrolled in my class. I'd be glad to recommend another coach.

Get in touch

Let's talk about your student.

Tell me where things stand, and I'll reply within two days with times for a free 15-minute call.

Or email me directly:

You'll get a ready-to-send email to copy into your own mail app.